Much has been made of late about exercise and its relation to weight loss. There was the Time cover story The Myth About Weight Loss and a recent article on the topic in the New York Times, which recommended working out in the fat burning zone.

You see the phrase on all types of cardio machines: the fat burning zone, aka the "weight loss zone," means working out at a lower intensity to burn fat as fuel. But these workouts also burn considerably fewer calories. I was confused about how we should all be spending our cardio time, so I took my questions to exercise physiologist Jason Karp, who also happens to be an avid runner.
When I asked him if we should all be scaling our workouts back and aiming for the fat burning zone, Karp explained that it's not the type of fuel your body is burning, but the overall calories that count. "It doesn't matter if you're using fat or carbohydrates. In order to lose fat from your waistline you don't have to be using fat as fuel during workout," he said. He offered up the example of sprinters; they don't train in the fat burning zone, but they're mighty trim in the torso. Losing weight comes down to math — you want to be in a calorie deficit to shed pounds and body fat. Higher intensity exercise puts you at a higher burn rate. To burn the most calories in a cardio workout, skip past the fat burning zone and work out with more intensity. To really burn up calories, Karp recommends intervals. To learn why, read more.
Essentially, interval workouts give you the most bang for your sweat buck. Karp explains that with "intense exercise you're pushing your body more out of homeostasis," that is, the equilibrium of energy the body prefers to maintain. During the few hours after an interval workout, the body must go through a recovery period, and a lot needs to happen to return to the body to pre-exercise levels. "You've got to drop the heart rate, synthesize glycogen for the muscles, remove lactate from muscle and take it to the liver," says Karp. All these actions require energy, which raises the metabolic rate for many hours after exercising. Thirty minutes of exercise at a low intensity doesn't place nearly as much stress on the body as intervals, so you burn fewer calories both during and after the workout.
Before you hit the track and start running intervals, Karp recommends building a strong cardiovascular fitness base and working with a trainer for guidance. Even if you're not ready for sprints, play with your speed during your next cardio session. Slow and steady might win the race, but intervals will burn more calories.
Source: Flickr User pistoldrawn
Urban Decay
I have been working out regularly since about Labor Day and found a really good cardio comfort zone. then maybe three to four weeks ago I (using a FitSugar print out
) turned to intervals. I see an INSANE difference in my body, and FEEL so much better after
my workouts. they're not for days when I'm feeling a little zapped of energy but I try to fit them in as much as possible. last night at the gym, I was trying to beat a time in addition to
alternating my comfort speed with a much faster speed, so included other steps, some sprints, some periods a little faster than my comfort, and cut 4 minutes of my regular time
1ummmm this goes completely against the other article you posted about working out not helping etc.
2Who cares about this crap. If you want to lose weight stop stuffing food in your face and go for a walk once a day.
3LaurenG22 —
4There are a lot of opinions on the matter and Jason Karp was clear that a physiologist would never recommend not exercising as part of a weight loss program. There is an ongoing conversation on the confusing subject, so here is another chunk of information.
Glad to see he knows what he's talking about. I'm pretty sick of these articles that are printing scientific studies out of context and making the results different than they are. None of the studies have really said that exercise doesn't work; they've suggested that caloric intake matters more. A terrible diet and a daily walk just isn't enough. Needing to exercise in the fat burning zone doesn't make sense either. It doesn't matter if you burn fat directly or burn the carbs, because the excess is going to end up as fat anyhow.
5Mamasitamalita-
So would you recommend intervals, then? "Insane difference" is really intriguing- I want that!!
6very informative
7Hmm. I just got dunked to have my BMI tested and I was told to stick to the fat burning zone, that if your heart rate is too high your body will start breaking your muscle down for fuel because it's the easiest at that point. Plus "low and slow" is what body-builders typically stick to to shed the fat off their body and keep their muscle. Interesting.
The best bet seems to be clean eating no matter what exercise you do, for maximum results. Supposedly it's 80% diet, 20% exercise that gets you were you need to be.
8Mamasita--following Fitsugar's printouts as well and adjusting to my level as well. I haven't run on the treadmill in months, so I'm doing the beginner level but am adding more speed to the higher ones each time so I end up going from a jog, to run, to sprint, to jog, to sprint etc. I haven't noticed anything yet... but i'm sure I will if I keep at it
The one thing that deters me tho is my knees.
9I do the majority of my cardio in the "fat-burning" zone, but I also do intervals to keep my body guessing. Ultimately, it comes down to calories...if you don't mind spending more time working out, you'll burn the same amount of calories in the fat burning zone as you would doing a shorter amount of high-intensity activity. I'm thinking most people probably want their workout over ASAP, so they benefit from a high-intensity interval workout.
10I'm so confused about what I should be doing now.
I start running 2 minutes at a time at 6.0
mph with a 1 minute rest. After doing 2 sessions of 6.0 mph at a time, I bump it up to 6.1 and so on, for 30-40 minutes. Is this wrong??
11It is, after all, an interval workout I found on FitSugar.
12Ive been doing the fitsugar treadmill workouts...and boy oh boy! what a difference. I love it! I am doing the intermediate level and after running I feel exhausted but great! Intervals are the way to go 4 sure.
13Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.