NOT JLo, and I refuse to vote for the psycho, body-obsessed Madonna. So I concluded Jen Aniston, though I think there's probably better choices out there than listed here. I like Evangeline Lilly! But she's probably too obscure.

I almost voted Jessica Biel, but lately she's been looking more normal than spectacular. WHICH is cool with me! I really like her. She's a normal person I think.

Who did a triathalon? If I had known who it was, I would have voted for her!

So Aniston!

hmm, i was wrong!!

Didn't JLo do a triathalon or something?

I'm with littlekaren on Evangeline Lilly, she's so toned! And I couldn't vote for man-arms Madonna. She scares me a little. I eventually went with Gwyneth Paltrow. That exercise segment that she did (posted on here a while ago), was really real, what with the red-faced sweatiness. It sort of endeared her to me a little.

Madonna is too over-done for me, so I voted Aniston.

Jessica Biel. If I were to look for "fitness" in a dictionary, I would find her physique. (If I were to look for "creepy and obsessed", it would be Madonna's picture.)

Reese Witherspoon and Jessica Biel strike the perfect balance between athleticism/fitness and femininity, I think. I hate that overly lean and muscular Madonna look.

Gwyneth's legs are amazing! She has the best fit body.

I said JLo. You know she's gotta work the hardest to keep that butt from being a bubble.

ugh, and that pic of madonna is less than flattering.

The comments here are so interesting -- and I mean that in a good way! Can I write in Gabrielle Reece? I voted Madonna but realized that being seemingly obsessed with fitness, which is only my limited perception admittedly, is not a paragon of health to which I aspire.

I never had a problem with Gywneth until her and her trainer went on Oprah and advocated that no woman should ever lift anything more than 3 pound weights. No woman who only lifts 3 pound weights and is stick thin with little muscle tone is not the fitest anything.

I voted for Biel because she has amazing muscle tone, and I give J.Lo a lot of credit for doing a tri.

I voted J.Lo because she ran a triathalon, but reese and biel are my close 2nd

Jessica Biel and Fergie are my 2 picks. Both of them seem really into being healthy and fit and both have nice bodies that I would love to have! I agree with everyone, I think Madonna looks gross. She just needs a little less .... I don't know.... something. .... I don't even know what it is, but it's gross. haha

Since it's Fittest Female Celeb in 2008 I've gotta vote for my girl JLo! She had twins and did a triathalon all in one year! How can you NOT vote for her this year??

kclulu--that's really interesting, because gwyneth and madonna have the same trainer, and madonna obviously lifts more than 3 lb. weights--her arms are scary!

i voted fergie, because she really seems to be into fitness, as opposed to just looking skinny. but if i could trade bodies with any of them, i would choose jennifer aniston.

Reese and Biel are my picks. They are both curvy and natural (i.e. don't have awkward Fergie boobs.) Sometimes Biel is a teeny bit too muscular for my taste, but otherwise she has what would be my ideal body. As for Madonna...I mean, what do you even say? Yes, she's fit; but I definitely think there is a point where you can take it too far. She passed that point a long time ago.

I vote for Jessica Biel. She's got nice muscular curves and she's not overly skinny or fake-looking.

I don't necessarily like Madonna's body image but I don't think you can argue with her physique. But let's stop one moment Ali Larter is NOT a celebrity and I'm upset that she's up there.

Twinkle: Yes Madonna and Gwyneth have the same trainer, which was why I was so suprised she would say that but here is a link to that quote: http://www.oprah.com/slideshow/oprahshow/20080828_tows_paltrow/3

The only explanation I could come up with is Madonna has such huge guns from yoga and bands. In that same link above she says that she developed a band routine for Madonna.

What about Kelly Ripa??

Can't we say that "fit" has more to do with the amount of exercise you do? Someone who exercises A TON and is clearly a bit obsessed *cough cough Madonna** is not fit, but unhealthy.

xxkrist- I agree. I don't even think Madonna is necessarily physically unhealthy with her extensive training, but her seeming obsession with fitness seems emotionally unhealthy. Obviously we can't know how body-obsessed any of the others are, but it does seem Madge takes it too far.

So I voted for Biel- she gets so much crap on pop for looking "manly" but I think her physique is actually quite attractive, and clearly she is very fit. I agree a couple of pictures she might have looked a little too muscular, but in general I'd say I'm pretty jealous. And Aniston always looks good, plus I love that she is a little older (nearly 40!) and still looks great- inspiration.

Madonna's body is gross.

I voted for Madonna because she works out like crazy. Jennifer Aniston has an amazing body. I find Jessica Biel, Fergie or Madonna quite manly.

Madonna. She seems really disciplined about her diet, too.

I voted for Jessica Biel. She has an awesome body which she obviously works hard for and I think she looks great! And it's hard not to be envious of that butt! I also love how she is always out walking her doggies, she's not a celebrity who have just used pets as a way to get attention *cough* Paris *couch* Keep up the good work girl!

I would have voted for Kelly Ripa!

While Madonna and Biel obviously do some serious training, I ended up choosing Reese Witherspoon.

My reason is because she seems to make fitness a priority in her life, but she doesn't let it run her life. You'll see her running in some pics and then eating ice cream with her kids in others.

That's the kind of "Fit" we need to see more of!

I liked Fergie's take on fitness after gaining weight for her movie and then working to lose it during Thanksgiving but not obsessing about it. Kelly Rippa and Kate Hudson seem to be very good fitness models too.

Aniston FTW!

I agree with Jude C and others here. Biel and Reese are great examples of fit women who retain their feminity without taking it to far (alla Madonna. she scares me o.o;; Never liked Aniston [just what is her appeal??])

I love Jessica Biel but I voted for Reese J.Lo would be my 3rd pick because she completed a triathalon. Anyone that can get through that deserves some props.

Madonna. Even tho she looks gross.

Jessica Biel
beats madonna !

Reese! She always seems to be exercising (with Jake!) and looks great.
(Madonna is scary looking...ewwww!)

technically... Madonna is, hands down... but i don't think she is the healthiest or happiest and that's part of being fit.

Also Felicity Huffman is SUPER-fit too. Most people don't realize that.