Quantcast
 

Just Say No to Nalgene?

Thu, 04/17/2008 - 2:00am by FitSugar
5,247 Views - 46 comments

The future may no longer be in plastics.

Another study linked the chemical bisphenol A, used to make hard, shatter proof plastics, to precancerous tumors, urinary tract problems and early puberty. The study was performed on rats that were fed or injected with small amounts of the chemical, and although the results are preliminary the group of scientists involved in the study said that possible effects on humans "cannot be dismissed." The National Toxicology Program, who headed the study, is comprised of scientists from many formidable national agencies: the Center for Disease Control, US Food and Drug Administrations, and the US Institutes of Health. Agencies not likely to be ignored considering that this study echoes findings made late last summer by the National Institute of Health.

Bisphenol A is ubiquitous and found in Nalgene bottles, that say polycarbonate (#7 on the bottom) as well as clear plastic baby bottles. It is also used as a liner for cans. Since this questionable chemical can leach into water or food that comes in contact with the hard plastic, many Canadian retailers have pulled products, like Nalgene bottles from their shelves. Once popular only with backpackers, Nalgene bottles have found a niche as reusable water bottle for thirsty folks working on decreasing their carbon and plastic footprint. There are other options like SIGG bottles, made from aluminum; they're lightweight, durable, and cute.

So say "No" to Nalgene and other polycarbonate plastics. I've made the switch and given up my lovely orange Nalgene bottle that I have used for years. What about you? Share the details in the comments section below.

Source

on Yahoo!

Related Fit Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

46 Comments Add a Comment

  • Hi D's picture
    Hi D
    1

    Number 7 is actually the designation given to all "other" plastics, so some bottles made from plastics like polymethylmethacrylate (which does not contain BPA) fall under this designation. If you are concerned, Lululemon makes a very cute PMMA bottle that is BPA free.

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • lcharelj's picture
    lcharelj
    2

    I got rid of mine and bought a Sigg aluminum bottle. It comes with different options for the tops and have cute and fun patterns on each bottle. A little expensive, but worth it to me.

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • wackdoodle's picture
    wackdoodle
    3

    I bought two SIGGS over the weekend to replace my beloved Nalgene bottles. I have to buy 4 more because my sister wants my nephews to switch to the SIGG bottles too.

    Only problem with the metal SIGG bottle is if you drop it or bang it against something hard it will dent.

    Otherwise I find that my water stays super cold for longer in the SIGG bottle.

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • kittyhill's picture
    kittyhill
    4

    I remember a few years back that everyone was telling you to switch TO Nalgene bottles because toxins leached from the softer plastics! With all of the studies that keep coming out, we're going to find out that EVERYTHING will kill us eventually.

    Call me a granolahead, I'm not abandoning my beloved Nalgene bottles so quickly!

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • saraswords's picture
    saraswords
    5

    This isn't the first time I heard about this. It's pretty scary considering how popular Nalgene bottles are...

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • millarci's picture
    millarci
    6

    Aw man...and I just bought a Nalgene bottle not too long ago....

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • julieulie's picture
    julieulie
    7

    I'm not worried and I'm not jumping off the Nalgene ship yet. There are so many carcinogens out there, and actually injecting mice with the chemical is a lot different than what may leach into your water. I haven't read the study yet, but it reminds me of when research said that artificial sweeteners may cause cancer... and they were giving the mice the equivalent of a human consuming multiple pounds per DAY. I'm sure a lot of people switching from Nalgene bottles still drink diet soda.

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • StanKjar's picture
    StanKjar
    8

    What about the risk of Alzheimers from using aluminum. There were concerns a little while ago that using aluminum cooking pops made people more likely to get Alzheimers. I doesn't sound like SIGG bottles are a much better option.

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • katebrandon's picture
    katebrandon
    11

    Aluminum only gives you alzheimers if it is heated up (like burning beer cans in a camp fire, a favorite of some of my friends). It is relatively inert when not heated.

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • nobodymuch's picture
    nobodymuch
    12

    I switched to alumninum for my water bottle, but I'm a bit more on the fence for food storage containers. The polycarbonate IS apparently more heat stable and better to microwave than other plastics, I've heard, and I'm not sure I'm worried enough to give that up, since there's not as good an alternative. I'll use glass when I can, but I'm going to keep reading.

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • tngirly's picture
    tngirly
    13

    Noooooo!!! My husband (who runs an outdoor adventure program) and I use Nalgenes 24/7! I can not give it up! I guess I might not live to be 100 anymore--- but I probably have not been putting enough into my retirement plan anyway so I will keep using my Nalgenes hoping that by the time the plastics kill me I will be at the end of my savings! Smiling

    37 weeks 6 days ago Report Comment
  • avienndha's picture
    avienndha
    14

    I was so annoyed to hear this news too! I loved my pink nalgene...*sniff*

    Now I drink from glass all day at work, and I'm jumping on the sigg bandwagon too I suppose...

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • secrethoughts's picture
    secrethoughts
    15

    My husband and I were formerly avid Nalgene fans, but we've recently made the switch to Kleen Kanteens, and we love 'em! I feel like the water stays colder longer and like it doesn't get that funky bottle smell all the time. Now if only it were so easy to give up all my plastic food storage containers at home...

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • cvandoorn's picture
    cvandoorn
    16

    Great and I just bought a Nike polycarbonate bottle...because i'm trying to help the environment. So much for that! But then again...everything can kill you. So i'm going to continue using it.

    I don't like the sigg bottles.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • jill37's picture
    jill37
    17

    I read up on SIGG bottles because the aluminum concerned me too, but there is a leach-proof liner inside the bottle so the liquid never touches the aluminum. Lots of independent studies have been done on SIGGS that suggest they're safe. And even though they can dent if hit really hard, the liner won't be compromised, so they stay safe even if they're a little scuffed up. I haven't bought one yet, but I plan to.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • ohkate's picture
    ohkate
    18

    a coworker of mine noticed I was drinking from a nalgene bottle and said he read an article that said the nalgene bottles can cause (facial) hair growth which freaked me out.

    guess I'll have to give up my bottle and either use a cup or find a different brand that won't kill me 10 years down the road or cause me to have to start shaving my face each week as well as my legs.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • nuttbecky's picture
    nuttbecky
    19

    We switched after reading some of the possible birth defects from the leaching - that was enough for me, and my nalgenes were getting scratched up anyway.

    We actually bought #2 bottles from resuablebags.com - I love that site. They sell reusable grocery bags and non-leaching water bottles and they support environmental charities. They stock the 32 oz nalgene and the 16oz nalgene sizes. The sigg bottles are cool looking, but I still love my nalgene and the 16 oz bottles fit into the cup holders at the gym really well.

    BYOB (Bring your own bag). I also suggest buying a bag or two while you are there! My favorite are http://www.reusablebags.com/store/envirosax-monochromatic-pouch-reusable... (keep in the back of the car for groceries)
    and http://www.reusablebags.com/store/reisenthel-mini-maxi-shopper-eden-long... (it is my lunch bag in the morning, rolls up in my purse to use for all the little trips I run during the day)

    Happy early Earth Day!

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • pinkmermaid23's picture
    pinkmermaid23
    20

    I read about this last year in an alternative health magazine and switched to a SIGG bottle immediately. Can you believe it is in baby bottles? I wonder when/if the U.S. will pull them from the shelves as well...

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • mondaymoos's picture
    mondaymoos
    21

    Everything causes cancer. I love my Nalgene bottle and I definitely don't plan on tossing it just to find out next week that a SIGG bottle has something in it that causes cancer too.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Soniabonya's picture
    Soniabonya
    22

    is nothing safe anymore? i lost my nagleene bottle, got another one and its been sitting in my car with 1/2 cup water left inside for the past month >_

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • citygirl2's picture
    citygirl2
    23

    what about a plastic thermos??? i guess i'll switch to a SIGG bottle, but i'm still worried about the alzheimers studies...

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • calliope's picture
    calliope
    24

    I have a water bottle that's half metal (on the top and bottom) and the rest is plastic. I'm going to go continue to drink out of it. As everyone else said, everything gives you cancer.
    P.S.- There's pharmaceutical drugs in the tap water.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Smilesp's picture
    Smilesp
    25

    I'm not giving up my nalgene bottle yet. People freak out about these types of articles too much. Most of the things we use everyday are not 100% safe, you can't protect yourself from everything.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • kia's picture
    kia
    26

    I've ditched my nalgene for a SIGG for everyday use. But backpacking season is coming up and my water purifier fits well on my nalgene openings so I'll use it for water storage then. I also still have my nalgene splash guard accessories that I don't know what to do with now either.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • MandyJoBo's picture
    MandyJoBo
    27

    Yep! Nalgene also manufactures animal-testing equipment for labs, so if you're the caring kind, that's another reason to not support them.

    I know that it's impossible to protect ourselves from everything, but, if you are aware of a potential concern and do nothing about it, you aren't doing everything you can to stay healthy ans safe. I feel better knowing I'm doing what I can--especially when it's as easy as switching water bottles.

    SIGG bottles are questionable now as well. They are lined, and the lining is suspected to contain trace amounts of BPA. SIGG won't deny or confirm either way.

    I use Kleen Kanteen.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • mondaymoos's picture
    mondaymoos
    30

    And when they find out that Kleen Kanteen causes cancer too, MandyJoBo? There's really no end to it.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • BriaGirl's picture
    BriaGirl
    31

    I love my nalgene bottle- it went with me almost everywhere, until a coworker made me watch the Today Show segment. . .so then I just stopped bringing it to work with me- but I still think it's stupid to toss the bottles just because ONE study says you have to

    What about all the cars on the streets? Doesn't the exhaust do horrible things to the body? If people can live in cities with all the possible carcinogens out there, I don't think one more is really going to make that big of a difference.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • allthingsgrow's picture
    allthingsgrow
    32

    I'm not giving up my Nalgene! Everyone I know at my school has one. It's healthier than re-using water bottles (which hold bacteria after a few uses) and I tried just using a glass container, but I dropped it and it obviously shattered.

    I hate the aluminum ones because they're not as easy to carry around and not as easy to drink out of.

    So I'll stick to my Nalgene, thanks!

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • dd sugar's picture
    dd sugar
    33

    My friend bugged me to get a Nalgene bottle but I never got around to it. He even used it for hot coffee (disaster when it slipped from his hands, scalding his bare leg, and breaking the glass blender!)

    After reading this post, I searched and found a great site today, ordering a Klean Kanteen bottle (has food grade stainless steel so OK for hot liquids) and several SIGG bottles that were on closeout price. They have a flat shipping fee for April, donate to earth causes and have safe baby stuff too (Getngreen.com).

    Thanks fitsugar for getting me in gear and ready for earthday!

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Spectra's picture
    Spectra
    35

    Nalgene makes almost ALL lab glassware; the only reason animal research labs buy it is because it's such a good product. It's not like they endorse the research or anything.

    I'm not abandoning my Nalgene bottle either. The only way stuff will leech out of your plastic bottle is if you put it in the dishwasher or microwave. To maintain your Nalgene bottle and keep it from leeching BPA, make sure that when you wash it, you use warm water, mild detergent and rinse it well. And don't freeze it with water in it and let it thaw because that can cause tiny cracks to form in the plastic that can weaken the plastic over time.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • ariel55's picture
    ariel55
    36

    I would recommend keeping calm and wait for the official review from health organization.

    If you read the original research paper, it doesn't appear to say the level detected in subjects are higher than safety standard. Check out the last sentence.

    Here's one:

    Bisphenol A (BPA) daily intakes in the United States: Estimates from the 2003-2004 NHANES urinary BPA data.
    Lakind JS, Naiman DQ.

    aLaKind Associates, LLC, Catonsville, Maryland, USA.

    Investigations into human exposure to bisphenol A (BPA) have, for the most part, assessed intake based on food consumption estimates combined with measurements or estimates of BPA in foods. In this study, nationally representative data on urinary levels of BPA in the United States (US) from the 2003-2004 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) were used to estimate daily intake of BPA, assuming steady-state excretion. Distributions of intakes for the US population were determined for (i) all NHANES participants with urinary BPA data; (ii) participants by the following age groups: 6-11 years, 12-19 years, 20-39 years, 40-59 years, and 60+ years; and (iii) participants by gender. On the basis of the NHANES urinary BPA data and the assumptions described in this paper, daily BPA intakes for male participants are statistically significantly higher than for female participants, and there are statistically significant differences in daily BPA intakes according to age groups, with the oldest group having the lowest estimated intakes. Median intake was approximately three orders of magnitude below health-based guidance values of 50 mug/kg-day.Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology advance online publication, 16 April 2008; doi:10.1038/jes.2008.20.

    37 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Vsugar's picture
    Vsugar
    38

    SIGG aluminum bottles are INDEED lined with the same cancer-causing plastics they are discussing here.

    The only good option is the kleen-kanteen which is unlined, stainless steel. I love mine - use it all the time.

    37 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • cereal_please's picture
    cereal_please
    39

    Seriously? There's no way I'm going to stop using something just because ONE study somewhere says there MIGHT be a link to cancer. There really are carcinogins everywhere. It is like the artificial sweeteners debate.. I'm most likely never ending my diet coke addiction, and a few mice getting cancer isn't likely to influence me either.

    37 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment
  • n00dledancer's picture
    n00dledancer
    41

    i have 3 nalgenes (different sizes) & a camelbak bottle right now. when it comes time to replace my nalgenes, i'll probably get a sigg for evryday use, but i love the camelbak one for the gym.

    37 weeks 4 days ago Report Comment